Organic food is not the answer

Organic food

In the sphere of trying to do what is right for the environment, a lot of people assume that eating organic food is the best thing to do as an individual, and maybe eating local food (reducing “farm miles”). Is this correct?

A recent online review of the facts, “Is organic farming better for the environment than conventional farming?”, suggests probably not. At best, the picture is mixed.

Hannah Ritchie, on the website Our World in Data, has surveyed analyses of conventional and organic farming as regards their impact on carbon emissions, water pollution, biodiversity, and land use.

A note, first, on what organic agriculture means. Ritchie describes it as: “...the farming of crops or livestock without the use of synthetic inputs. That includes synthetic fertilisers, pesticides, plant growth regulators, nanomaterials, and genetically modified organisms (GMOs).”

Ritchie writes: “Organic agriculture almost always proved better on the metric of ‘ecotoxicity’. This measures how harmful a farming system’s chemical inputs — which are mostly pesticides — are to plants, insects, and aquatic life in the local environment.”

And: “organic farming also tends to support greater biodiversity on the land it uses”. She relies on “data from a large meta-analysis by Fatemeh Hashemi and colleagues, published in Communications Earth & Environment in 2024.” These are important considerations.

However, “conventional agriculture consistently performed better on land use. It had higher yields of both plant and animal products, so producing one kilogram of food required less land”. “Organic practices used 64% more land”.

Counter

Reforestation, rewilding, and halting the clearing of forest for more crop and grazing land, is one of the ways we hope to restore nature and the environment, through carbon capture and improving biodiversity. Yet organic farming runs counter to that.

What about other dimensions?

“The researchers found that across the 100 assessments, there was no statistically significant difference between organic and conventional farming when it came to greenhouse gas emissions, acidification, and eutrophication [leakage of nutrients into land and water bodies].”

Ritchie says that most important for the environment is what we eat. “Reducing food miles might change the carbon footprint of your food choices by 5% to 10%. Changing what you eat could change it by ten times or more. That’s because the difference in greenhouse gas emissions between animal products such as beef or lamb, and plant-based ones like soy is so large”.

Ritchie explained this in a 2020 article. “You want to reduce the carbon footprint of your food? Focus on what you eat, not whether your food is local”, where she says:

“Overall, animal-based foods tend to have a higher footprint than plant-based. Lamb and cheese both emit more than 20 kilograms of CO2-equivalents per kilogram. Poultry and pork have lower footprints but are still higher than most plant-based foods, at 6 and 7 kg CO2-equivalents, respectively”.

Comparing the benefits and harms of conventional and organic agriculture, crucially, Ritchie says, “it’s estimated that around half of the global population today relies on synthetic fertiliser for the food they eat.”

Organic agriculture doesn’t have an answer to how to achieve the same yields to feed everyone.

Harness

Socialists believe we can harness scientific knowledge and collectively organise society, industry, the economy — the world — to serve human goals rather than serving the interests of the rich, capitalist few as happens at present. When we do this we can take care of and restore the environment on which we all depend.

When we do this, we can find ways to change “conventional” agriculture, reducing agrochemical use and making it less toxic and better for diversity.

Eating organic food might make individuals feel better in themselves and that they are doing their part for the environment, but it’s a delusion that it’s having a large beneficial effect.

People would do better to get involved in socialist politics, helping to organise the social force — the working class — that can make the real difference to what we eat and how it’s produced.

Comments?
We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.