“When I die, you’ll be the last man standing. Keep the flag flying.” Thus did Derek Hatton, introducing the inaugural Tony Mulhearn Memorial Lecture in Liverpool on Monday 28 September, recall one of his last conversations with Mulhearn, who died in 2019. Hatton and Mulhearn had been two of the 47 Liverpool councillors surcharged and banned from holding office in 1985 for having delayed setting a rate.
Hatton did not expand upon which flag he was meant to keep flying. Since his departure from the Council many of the flags he has flown have certainly been well short of “deepest red”:
A series of TV adverts for Sekonda watches; his much-in-demand services as an after-dinner speaker; voice of the bloke radio show presenter (compulsory curfew for teenagers, mandatory contraceptive implants in all baby girls, etc.); director of a cosmetic surgery and botox clinic; director of a company selling properties in Cyprus; ….
Hatton’s politics have also — ahem — evolved over time. In a 2008 interview with the Liverpool Echo he said: “It’s property developers that have transformed Liverpool. Don’t forget, this city is now a much better place despite the council — it’s because of outside developers and the private sector.”
Mystery
Quite why the Socialist Party — one of the successors to the Militant tendency, the decisive political force in the Liverpool 47 — found it fitting to have such a charlatan on the platform is a mystery which only the Socialist Party can explain.
Sharing the platform with Hatton was former Unite General Secretary Len McCluskey, introduced by the meeting’s chair as “a real comrade and friend, he was and is a Liverpudlian.”
McCluskey hailed the revolutionary fervour of Liverpool in the mid-1980s. “The meetings in the Smolny Institute in Petrograd in 1917 must have been like the meetings of the City Labour Party.”
The Smolny Institute was the headquarters of the Bolsheviks, from where they organised the October Revolution.
McCluskey sidestepped the obvious problems with his analogy. Such as the fact that the Bolsheviks did not issue the entire Petrograd workforce with notices of dismissal as a “tactical manoeuvre”, while borrowing £30 million from Swiss banks in order to avoid confrontation with the Provisional Government.
What laid low the Liverpool 47, claimed McCluskey, was the same force which subsequently laid low Corbyn: “The establishment, the real establishment, the people who really run our lives. Their friends across the pond [McCluskeyese for: CIA] would have been on the phone to them: How have you ended up allowing this to happen?”
Participation
McCluskey got a thumbs-up from Socialist Party members in the audience when he recommended reading Liverpool: A City That Dared to Fight, a self-serving Socialist Party mythology of events in Liverpool in the mid-1980s.
But he got a thumbs-down when he recommended that anyone in the audience not already in a political party join Your Party. That was not what Socialist Party members wanted to hear.
To be fair to him, McCluskey excelled in audience participation. In a cross between a morality play and a Christmas pantomime, McCluskey invited the audience to pass judgement on politicians past and present.
“Was Tony Mulhearn on our side? (Yes!). “Was Neil Kinnock on our side?” (No!) “Was Jeremy Corbyn on our side?” (Yes!) “Was Keir Starmer on our side?” (No!)
Things got a bit complicated when McCluskey asked: “Is Andy Burnham on our side?” The audience member who had been standing outside of Labour Party conference denouncing Burnham as a fascist certainly did not think so. Nor did the audience member who advocated a general strike because Burnham had failed to call Gaza a genocide.
There were a lot of keffiyehs on display at the meeting. Even some Socialist Party members, including the chair, had donned one on. How times change!
The right answer to the question, according to McCluskey, was: “Wait and see.”
But it could have been worse. McCluskey refrained from asking “Is Derek Hatton on our side?” And no-one had the temerity to ask the question: “Are the Flanagan brothers on our side?”
Along with Hatton and former Liverpool Lord Mayor Joe Anderson, the Flanagan brothers, who run a property development company of the same name, are currently awaiting trial to face charges of bribery and conspiracy to commit bribery in relation to contracts awarded by Liverpool City Council.
Are they perhaps an example of the “property developers that have transformed Liverpool” so admired by Hatton?
By coincidence, the Flanagan brothers are also McCluskey’s personal friends and were awarded the contract — in the absence of a competitive tendering process — to build Unite’s Birmingham hotel and conference centre during his terms of office as General Secretary.
The initial estimated cost of the project was £57 million. In the event, Unite was charged £112 million — even though the hotel and conference centre are currently valued at only £37 million. Investigations into the overcharging and serial financial irregularities are continuing.
“Are the Flanagan brothers on our side?” would certainly have been a tricky one to answer. Perhaps the correct answer would have been: “Yes, but only if you’re standing in the dock, or may do so at some point in the future, alongside of them.”
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us