Around 200 people attended the Green-run Hackney Council’s “ant-austerity summit” on 9 September, mostly councillors and trade unionists, and a smaller number of party members, mainly Greens. Holding the meeting Wednesday daytime was always going to limit those who could attend.
The initiative’s political direction remains unclear, but if it can help build local labour movement-focused anti-cuts committees, it may play a useful role. That it was addressed by the Chief Executive of Hackney Council was not a good start. The central issue was whether councils, particularly those controlled by the Greens, should refuse to set cuts budgets in spring 2027 and instead prepare for a confrontation with the government with some variant of a “no-cuts” or “no social-cuts” budget.
Zoë Garbett, Mayor of Hackney, made it clear that her administration would not put itself in a position where government commissioners could be appointed. This appeared to set an important limit on how far Hackney, and potentially other councils, would be prepared to challenge central government. If everyone waits for another to put their head above the parapet, and to get the “critical mass” we heard from a number of participants, then very little will happen.
The campaign has five principal “asks”. These were “agreed” in a messy consensus process, “consensus” meaning how supportive Zoë Garbett was to any proposal from the floor. Intervention on the campaign demands achieved some useful changes. The demand for “social housing” was sharpened to a demand for council housing, and “improvements” in pay was replaced with a demand for full restoration of what workers have lost. The attempt to take a stronger position against council tax was less successful.
1. More government funding: Restore and replace Local Government Financial Settlements to at least pre-2010 levels, with guaranteed funding for both statutory and non-statutory service delivery. This should be determined primarily on the basis of need, with structural changes made to meet that need.
2. Cancel local authority debt: Break the cycle of local authorities scrambling to get back on their feet, and let them start a new chapter that ensures residents benefit first.
3. More funding for council homes: Provide capital funding to significantly increase the number of council homes built and put to use every year, and ensure a long-term financial commitment to high-quality, accessible and sustainable provision. This must entail ending right-to-buy as it has functioned, and ending the developer-led model.
4. New, fairer ways to raise money: Reform council tax and introduce new ways for councils to raise funds, that ensures wealthier property and land owners pay a fairer share
5. Strengthening our public sector: From increasing powers to local councils, bringing in national regulations to systematically end outsourcing and privatisation practices, funding new models of work such as four-day working weeks, and restoration to public sector pay, disparity and conditions.
It was not clear how these demands would be presented, pursued or translated into a coordinated campaign. The immediate proposals included:
• Supporting an anti-austerity protest called by Hackney trade unions on the eve of the national Budget on 27 October.
• Supporting a protest against Palantir.
• Holding an expanded anti-austerity summit later in the year.
• Organising a national demonstration early in 2027.
• Building local organisations involving supportive councillors, trade union branches or trades councils, and wider communities.
The eve-of-Budget demonstration was supported, although several people questioned whether a protest held so close to the Budget would have much influence over its contents. The proposals for a further summit and national demonstration remained unresolved.
There was agreement that local groups should be developed, along with some mechanism through which trade union branches could affiliate. The Socialist Party proposed holding another conference before February, involving councils committed to no-cuts budgets, trade union branches and members of union executives or national committees.
A number of Green councillors, especially those from Haringey, said they wanted to refuse to set cuts budgets in spring 2027, provided several councils could be lined up to act together. One councillor warned against the Greens becoming “Labour 2.0” by repeating Labour councils’ role in implementing austerity.
Some councillors appeared to believe that a sufficiently large group of councils could collectively refuse cuts budgets and force the government to respond.
However, the discussion did not establish what would happen if the government responded with intervention, financial restrictions or the appointment of commissioners. Garbett’s position in Hackney suggested that avoiding this outcome would be a priority: refusing cuts budgets may be politically attractive, but unless councils are prepared to confront the consequences, the threat may remain largely symbolic.
The Socialist Party’s presentation of no-cuts budgets also came across as somewhat mechanical, and as Workers’ Liberty bulletin for the event said “any ‘unbalanced’ budget is now, by law, invalid, and an unelected council Financial Officer is legally required to refuse it”. Even so, the proposal was treated as though passing a budget itself would be the central act of resistance. What is needed is organisation outside council chambers to defend councillors who refused to implement cuts and to be part of a coordinated campaign with the local unions, tenants and community that could fight the government for greater funding.
The financial position of councils further complicates the strategy. Workers’ Liberty has argued that councils could buy time by using reserves and other available resources to delay cuts while building a campaign. Some councillors responded that many authorities are already so financially depleted that this may be difficult or impossible. The key question is therefore not simply whether councils can pass no-cuts budgets, but whether they can use the budget process to build the wider power required to sustain resistance.
Michael Chessum, a cabinet member in Lambeth, introduced the campaigning session with an assessment of the anti-austerity movement of the 2010s. He argued that the current situation should not be treated as a simple continuation of that earlier movement. The present campaign lacks some of the previous movement’s strengths, notably a major student revolt, but may possess a political expression that was absent 15 years ago: councils that are at least nominally prepared to challenge austerity.
The fact is that local government unions will not be striking over pay, and we do not yet have a radicalised labour movement prepared to fight cuts but not being held back by right-wing or over-cautious councillors. Unions will need to do a huge amount of work to prepare for a serious confrontation. At the same time, successful local disputes and forthcoming changes to balloting legislation suggest the situation has potential.
One unresolved issue concerns the balance between demanding increased central government funding and demanding greater powers for councils to raise revenue locally. The case for additional local revenue-raising powers is understandable, particularly where a narrow and regressive funding system prevents councils from meeting social needs. However, relying too heavily on local revenue would place the greatest burden on deprived areas. Councils serving poorer communities would have to raise taxes more aggressively to obtain the same resources as wealthier authorities, while still facing much greater levels of need.
The demand to tax wealth and big business should therefore be much more prominent. Tax the rich to pay for our services!
The campaign needs to make clear that the resources required to repair public services cannot be obtained principally by squeezing local residents, even through a reformed council-tax system.
This question was partly obscured by the economic presentation being given by Labour councillor Simon Ripton, an enthusiast for “Modern Monetary Theory”. To be sure, Ripton was right to reject the simplistic claim that the state budget must be managed like a household budget. A government that issues its own currency is not financially equivalent to a household, and austerity cannot be justified through that analogy. But for many decades now no economist, however right-wing, has believed the household analogy. Rachel Reeves was running a 5.5% deficit. The Tories ran large deficits from 2010, and huge ones in 2020-1. And actually MMTers also believe that there is a limit to deficits, set, they say, by controlling inflation. MMT seems to offer a technical “quick fix” avoiding class conflict - just print more money - but does not even do that.
The weakness of MMT was evident when Councillor Simon Ripton claimed that “government debt is our wealth”, as though UK government bonds were held equally across the population rather than being disproportionately owned by financial institutions and some wealthy households.
A similar problem appeared when the same councillor described children being held back by education cuts as representing “millions of hours of productive labour lost”. The material consequences of cuts should be understood primarily in terms of damage to people’s lives, capabilities and communities, rather than only as lost economic productivity.
If local groups get off the ground then Workers’ Liberty supporters will seek to be involved and to build these into broad labour-movement anti-cuts committees.
Comments?We welcome replies, corrections and debate pieces. Contact us