Israel, Hamas, and us

awl gaza

A letter from the editor

The “Neither Netanyahu, nor Hamas” headline we had last week was wrong.

It could be read as like “neither Israel, nor Hamas”. That is not our view.

We are for “two states” the right of both nations to self-determination and to defend themselves. Israel has the right to defend itself. The Israel of today, not just a future internationalist Israel, has a right to defend itself against attacks like 7 October, and to seek to disable and deter the attackers, as well as against being totally wiped out. The right to self-determination for nations is not conditional on nations being virtuous.

There is no equivalent “right to defend itself” for the revanchist theocratic-fascist movement Hamas.

The civilian population of Gaza has the right to defend itself, but because of political expropriation by Hamas lacks the means.

We call for ceasefire and peace because in the current Israeli military action, as shaped by Netanyahu’s chauvinist government, the element of self-defence is swamped by horrors against the civilian population of Gaza.

Hamas is embedded in the civilian population and hides in and under civilian buildings. That cannot justify the Israeli military’s seeming indifference to the huge civilian casualties. There has got to be a better way.

In any case this way is no good.

Netanyahu’s policy won’t “destroy Hamas”. In the medium term it, and the increased Israeli violence in the West Bank, will raise up new recruits for Hamas itself or similar groups (in the West Bank, in Lebanon, in the Palestinian diaspora, as well as in Gaza). The US war in Afghanistan 2001-2021 and Israel’s war in Lebanon 1982-2000 teach us that.

Netanyahu’s government has no workable “endgame” for its military, so will flounder. The floundering, and pressure of the ultra-rightists within the government, may well bring even worse than the horrors we already see.

Hamas wants to continue and spread the war to the maximum with no regard to civilian casualties. It will be a bad outcome if it can do that, eventually grind down the Israeli military, and emerge triumphant from the conflict.

The idea with the headline was to signal opposition to the horrors against Gaza’s people. But it wasn’t clear.

In current “pro-Palestine” marches, with chants and placards dominated by “Free Palestine, from the river to the sea” and similar, it has become almost an “un-fact” that this episode began with the murder of 1,200 Israelis, including small children, and the kidnapping of 240 Israeli hostages. Hamas did to them what it and its allies (Hezbollah, Iran) would do to all Israeli Jews if they could, if the forces of the Israeli state did not exist. Despite the official ceasefire slogan, those marches are not peace or anti-war marches, but anti-Israel, pro-Hamas war marches by sections of the left and by political Islamists and others for whom destroying Israel is the aim. We differ. If we could leave aside the question of methods, we are in favour of Israel suppressing Hamas.

We can’t detail what would be good self-defensive action; we can’t be military advisers to the Israeli government. It got here by stalling all peace negotiations for 20 years now, seeking to “contain” the Palestinians indefinitely in scattered patches of land (165 patches in the West Bank, plus Gaza), and more...

We call for peace. At present there is no agency for peace. We build support for movements like Standing Together which are the nucleus of a future agency.

Comrades may disagree. Let’s discuss it.

Martin Thomas

Comments

What does "suppress" mean? Were 'we' also in favour of the British Army "suppressing" the IRA? Even though we disagreed with the IRA's politics and the armed struggle? Were 'we' in favour of Putin's forces "suppressing" the neo-Nazi Azov battalion?

Surely what's needed is to undercut Hamas' support by finding a route to a viable Palestinian state, not advocating military action against it by the IDF, even in some imaginary way that would avoid collateral damage. 

Also, repeating Tory press narratives about the marches is unhelpful as well as asking for trouble. No doubt some present did support Hamas; I find it very doubtful that it was the majority.

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.