Review: The Right to Sex

Amia Srinivasan and The Right to Sex cover

Andi Brookes reviews The Right to Sex (2021), by Amia Srinivasan


When does disappointing sex turn into sexual assault? Is it ever right for teachers to sleep with their students? Should kids be exposed to “age-appropriate” porn? Does anyone have an inalienable right to sex, no matter how horrid they are? When was the last time you thought about the influence the global capitalist patriarchy has on your sex life?

It’s not often we confront our desires through a political lens in the 2020s. Most modern discourse on sex adopts either a positive, girl-boss empowerment approach to sexual encounters or takes an oppositional prudish stance. Neither of these perspectives reflect the realities of sexual politics today, and to continue the pretence that we live in a post-Cosmopolitan world consisting solely of de-politicised bodily autonomy and enthusiastic consent, in an era of anti-trans panic and the rolling back of abortion rights, seems futile. The Right to Sex, a collection of essays by Amia Srinivasan, deliberately attempts to bring the political lens back to this corner of the discourse, delving into the awkward, messy and sometimes infuriating world of our sex lives under capitalism and the patriarchy.

Bringing historical feminist debates out of the archives and dusting them off for another generation, the essays touch on a range of different areas, from the impact of carceral approaches to sexual assault, to the factors at work around teacher-student relationships. It’s a useful exercise in feminist analysis to trace the roots of current thinking back to debates litigated in the 1960s and ‘70s, although it might have been interesting to dive further back still. There is also significant critique of the carceral approach that mainstream feminism has tended to rely on to deliver justice, a theme that crops up several times throughout the essays. Srinivasan places the racial and class hierarchies in capitalist society centre-stage, and this reliance on carceral solutions goes about as well as you might expect on each occasion, with men of colour, queer porn producers, and immigrants caught in the crossfire.

Parts make for uncomfortable reading. In the titular ‘Right to Sex’ - the stand out essay of the collection - Srinivasan poses the provocative question of whether everyone should have access to sex and intimacy, regardless of other characteristics. The debate is situated against the backdrop of violence driven by white males identifying as “involuntary celebates” or incels, embodying the very worst of patriarchal sexual entitlement, spilling over into unbound offline rage. It’s actually quite sad then, when the essay explains that the original “incel” website was set up by a lonely queer Canadian looking for connection and community. The chapter goes on to challenge the reader to think about who they find sexually attractive and why, making us explore the ways in which our sexualities have been shaped by the bigotries and prejudices of wider society.

Are men the enemy, or is it the patriarchal capitalist system? Should we be stridently rejecting sex with men as a manifestation of patriarchy or does this deny us our own agency and control of our sex lives? What does it even mean to desire and be desired, particularly if you identify as a heterosexual women? This topic is one that could form the basis of an entire book itself, so it’s a bit disappointing that the book loses some steam from this high point. A long, disjointed series of paragraphs follows, addressing criticisms of the ‘Right to Sex’ essay following its initial publication in 2018. While the points raised do add to the commentary, the fact that they’ve clearly been taken from social media means that the whole thing feels like a very long Twitter thread.

The book joins Mithu Sanyal’s Rape: From Lucretia to #MeToo in critiquing and re-examing society’s perceptions of sex and relationships and attempting to find nuance in topics that are often presented as superficially black and white in today’s media. Reminding ourselves that our bodies and our desires remain political and a site of struggle feels like a sigh of relief, after several decades of insistence that all our problems could be solved with readily available contraception and clear consent. Those searching for answers in The Right to Sex might be disappointed though, since few of the essays come down in a firm stance in their conclusions or contain much in the way of concrete recommendations, which can be frustrating if you’re looking for the road to true sexual liberation. Except that it is definitely not okay to sleep with your students, in case that was unclear.


Live in or near London? Come along to our monthly socialist feminist reading group in Brixton, hosted by our South West London branch. Each time - currently the first sunday of the month - we have an informal discussion about a book, which might be a new release or a classic from the movement. Recent titles include The Right to Sex; Berlin’s Third Sex, by Magnus Hirchfeld; The Transgender Issue, by Shon Faye; and Rape, by Mithu Sanyal.

For more information write to: womensfightback@workersliberty.org

We use cookies on our website to support technical features that enhance your user experience.

We also use analytics & advertising services. To opt-out click for more information.