On 7 August, fascists from Patriotic Alternative turned up in Leeds to protest Drag Queen Story Hour. These storytimes for kids, where stories are read by drag performers, originated in San Francisco in 2016. Author Michelle Tea, who is behind the events, sought to “inspire a love of reading, while teaching deeper lessons on diversity, self-love and an appreciation of others”.
The vast majority of people would surely see this as innocuous fun and it has proved to be very popular, spreading across the US and overseas. However, from 2019 onwards, white supremacists and neo-Nazis in America began to target these events, accusing them of “sexualising kids” and pushing “gender ideology”. Now, the far right didn’t protest pantomime dames, picket Mrs Doubtfire, or burn Enid Blyton books. Gender fluidity has been a mainstay in children’s literature and media for a long long time, but the wave of trans- and homophobia we’re seeing now is something new.
Leeds Pride was due to host three of these events, hosted by Aida H Dee, until Patriotic Alternative announced their plans to protest. The council switched the plan from three events across three different libraries to two sessions at the central library in the city centre. Concerns over safety are understandable, but it provided the bigots and fascists with a win from the get go.
Patriotic Alternative are a relatively new group, founded by Mark Collett and others. Collett is a notorious figure on the far right. He was the leader of the Young BNP, who has been exposed as a Hitler admiring holocaust denier in a Channel 4 documentary. Unlike the biggest far right groups of the last decade, who at least pretended to reject biological racism, Patriotic Alternative are openly white nationalists and antisemitic.
A counterprotest against Patriotic Alternative was organised quickly and on the day. between 150 and 200 anti-fascists, trade unionists and young LGBT and queer people faced off across barriers against 40 to 50 members of Patriotic Alternative, with the entrance to the library and art gallery in between.
Patriotic Alternative did not seem to have brought anyone else from either the far right or “gender critical” movement with them. This is different from the situation elsewhere and may reflect how toxic PA are even on the far right. Their placards and speeches accused the event of grooming children and called their opponents paedophiles.
There was a bit of a dearth of politics on the anti-fascist side. Most of the chants were just “go home”, “whose streets our streets”, etc. The protest was also rather performative: there was no attempt by either side to push back each other or leave the pre-arranged protest point. But by all accounts both sessions of the Story Hour were full and the kids really enjoyed it. It was good to outnumber the fascists and the energy amongst the crowd was fantastic.
Patriotic Alternative claim they got what they wanted out of the day but their failure to bring out more than their own members surely suggests that this is not working to build the group, and that they’re losing the argument.