Submitted by cathy n on 18 December, 2012 - 2:57
Debate between Moshe Machover and Sean Matgamna
- Download the whole Machover-Matgamna debate
- Moshe Machover: "AWL - Abominable Warmongering Left"
- "Israel, Iran, and socialism". Sean Matgamna replies to Moshe Machover
- "Zionism: propaganda and sordid reality". Moshe Machover replies to Sean Matgamna
- "Israel and the 'essence of Zionism'". Sean Matgamna responds to Moshe Machover's second polemic.
- Two states - or no hope for either nation - third article by Sean Matgamna, dealing with a lecture in which Moshe Machover outlined his programme on Israel/Palestine
- Report of the Matgamna-Machover debate in London on 12 October
- Audio files (mp3) of the complete 12 October debate
AWL editorials
The discussion article which sparked the debate
Debate and polemic following that article, other than the Machover-Matgamna exchange
- Iran and Israel: debating the issues. A selection (various authors)
- No to an Israeli attack on Iran! (Sacha Ismail)
- No to any attack on Iran: for working-class resistance to imperialisms big and small (Daniel Randall)
- "How I came to advocate an Israeli nuclear strike on Iran" (Sean Matgamna, replying to the Weekly Worker's "interpretation")
- Q & A on Israel-Iran (Martin Thomas)
- Ambiguities in the Third Camp (Bruce Robinson)
Other relevant reading
- Iran, Israel, and nuclear weapons (the back page article on the question in the same issue of Solidarity as carried the original discussion piece)
- When Marxists fall out: in defence of Sean Matgamna (Philip Bounds)
- The Weekly Worker group (CPGB) and its fatuous gossip sheet: The Cheshire cat of Stalinism
- The Weekly Worker group ("CPGB"): Under the sign of the oxymoron
Attachment | Size |
---|---|
Israel, the Palestinians, and Iran_ a debate - Sean Matgamna & Moshe Machover.epub(571.4 KB) | 571.4 KB |
Israel, the Palestinians, and Iran_ a debate - Sean Matgamna & Moshe Machover.mobi(668.06 KB) | 668.06 KB |