Disentangling entropy, energy, Marxism, and ecological economics
The “left” has a long and ignoble tradition of the spinning or selective reading of thinkers, activists, or traditions: building a cardboard army to back up this or that position.
The “left” has a long and ignoble tradition of the spinning or selective reading of thinkers, activists, or traditions: building a cardboard army to back up this or that position.
Two years ago we said that we would write a pamphlet on the ecological crises. In the course of attempting that we realised there was a need for further study and discussion. We should use the conference period to discuss the controversial issues that have arisen from this study in more detail, clarify the lines of agreement and disagreement. This document is not intended as a comprehensive statement but simply an attempt to move these discussions forward. I think for a long time we only really thought about climate change as the big ecological problem. More recently we have come to see...
Pic: @gewman The Asian heatwave has broken hundreds of temperature records across over a dozen countries. Thailand (45.4°C), Vietnam (44.1°C) and Turkmenistan (42.2°C) have all experienced national records. In Maharastra, India, 13 people died and over a hundred people were hospitalised with heat stroke at an outdoor award ceremony. In Chiang Mai, Thailand, heat and the burning of crop residues have created a noxious smog that has overwhelmed health services with patients suffering respiratory problems. In Tripura and West Bengal, India, schools closed due to the rising temperatures. Record...
Tens of thousands of people participated in the 22 April central London march that marked the highpoint of Extinction Rebellion’s 21-24 April, “The Big One”, a long weekend of events and protests. Workers’ Liberty was there, as were some other socialists and trade unionists, including the organised XR Trade Unionists grouping. The civil service union PCS officially backed the event. There are left-wing, class-struggle-oriented stirrings in the XR milieu, or at least on its edges. At The Big One XR Trade Unionists ran a lively and interesting “hub” with speakers, ran stalls, collected contacts...
Zack Muddle’s response to my critique of Andreas Malm (30 March 2022) is to dismiss it as “much ado about nothing”. Zack says there is “much to agree with and of value” in my articles, although does not say what is acceptable. Zack denies we have “major and profound disagreement”. Actually, there remain significant differences that cannot be glossed over. Zack’s response is – sticking with Shakespeare – a comedy of errors. The disagreement centres on Malm’s book, Fossil Capital (2016), which Zack still believes is a useful contribution to Marxist ecology. I strongly dispute that and see it as...
Extinction Rebellion (XR)’s “Big One” plans action and workshops across London on 21-24 April: details here . This is the first XR action where there are no official plans for road blockades and civil disobedience. XR activists hope that veering away from their previous “maximum arrests” tactic will broaden their appeal, and more than 200 organisations are now supporting the event including the PCS civil service union. On Friday and Monday, XR plans “people’s pickets” of all major governmental departments. These “pickets” have been billed as a way to lobby civil servants and decision-makers on...
After nearly two decades of talks, the UN has agreed a treaty to protect the high seas from overfishing, shipping and extractive industry. The High Seas Treaty is the latest and potentially the most extensive curb on maritime capitalism to date. Although the treaty is very limited due to the commitment of the world’s capitalist states to the growth of fishing, mining and shipping capital, it is a significant step forward. Until recently, the seas have been treated as both inexhaustible resource tap and infinite waste dump. But this illusion is becoming difficult to sustain as the ocean...
Workers’ Liberty exists to catalyse workers’ struggle and organisation so we can replace capitalist direction of our labour by the “free association of producers”, democratically coordinated to social and environmental purpose. Part of that is workers’ plans for the ecological crisis. In recent months, North Sea offshore workers have devised a plan to shut down the oil and gas wells and use their skills and plant to build offshore wind and tidal power. This will require public ownership not only of the fossil fuel industry but also the ports and surrounding infrastructure. We work for the...
See a reply to this in the comments . Kohei Saito’s eagerly anticipated new book, Marx in the Anthropocene: Towards the Idea of Degrowth Communism (Cambridge University Press, 2023) will likely gain a wider readership. Ultimately, Saito’s book is disappointing, promising a new version of Marx, but instead reading back badly-formulated contemporary ideas. The book demonstrates that even when starting from solid premises, it is still possible to go wildly astray. Saito deservedly won many plaudits for his first book, Karl Marx’s Ecosocialism (2017) – reviewed in Solidarity 523 (30 October 2019)...
This website uses cookies, you can find out more and set your preferences here.
By continuing to use this website, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.